Constitutional principles and defensive jurisprudence
DOI:
10.16928/e20200902009Keywords:
Defensive jurisprudence Brazilian Superior Court of Justice Federal Constitution Constitutional principles Primacy of the decision on the meritsAbstract
This writing will focus on the so-called "defensive jurisprudence" inside Brazilian Superior Court of Justice, comparing with constitutional principles, such as access to justice and due process. The article will start from the conceptualization of the term "defensive jurisprudence", especially according to the doctrine, and from clarifications about its application during the validity of the Civil Procedure Code of 1973. The study will move towards an analysis of the guidelines of the current Code of Civil Procedure, by privileging decisions on merit - this being, even, a north that permeates all legislation -, comparing with the previous legal diploma, as well as the Federal Constitution. At the end, there will be a critical analysis of recent judgments of the Superior Court of Justice on the subject, bringing to debate the provocation that entitles this article.
References
BARBOSA MOREIRA, José Carlos. Restrições ilegítimas ao conhecimento dos recursos. São Paulo: Revista dos Tribunais, v. 386, 2006.
CÂMARA, Alexandre Freitas. O princípio da primazia da resolução do mérito e o Novo Código de Processo Civil. Disponível em http://genjuridico.com.br/2015/10/07/o-principio-da-primazia-da-resolucao-do-merito-e-o-novo-codigo-de-processo-civil/. Acesso em 22.03.20.
MEDINA, José Miguel Garcia. Novo Código de Processo Civil Comentado. 5. ed. São Paulo: Revista dos Tribunais, 2017.
NERY, Nelson; ANDRADE NERY, Rosa Maria. Código de Processo Civil Comentado. 16. ed. São Paulo: Revista dos Tribunais, 2016.
OLIVEIRA, Pedro Miranda de. O princípio da primazia do julgamento do mérito recursal no CPC projetado: óbice ao avanço da jurisprudência defensiva. São Paulo: Revista dos Tribunais, v. 950, 2014.
VAUGHN, Gustavo Fávero. Jurisprudência defensiva e processo incivil. In: RIBEIRO, Sérgio Luiz de Almeida; BIAZOTTI, Thiago D'áurea Cioffi Santoro (coord.). Entre o Processo Civil e o Processo Incivil. São Paulo: Editora Lualri, 2019.
WAMBIER, Teresa Arruda Alvim; CONCEIÇÃO, Maria Lúcia Lins; RIBEIRO, Leonardo Ferres da Silva; TORRES DE MELLO, Rogério Licastro. Primeiros Comentários ao Novo Código de Processo Civil. 2. ed. São Paulo: Revista dos Tribunais, 2016.
WAMBIER, Teresa Arruda Alvim; DIDIER JR, Fredie; TALAMINI, Eduardo; DANTAS, Bruno. Breves Comentários ao Novo Código de Processo Civil. 1. ed. São Paulo: Revista dos Tribunais, 2015.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
Authors retain copyright in their work and grant the journal the right of first publication. The licence applicable to this article is the one stated on its own page and corresponds to the policy in force on its date of publication.
Authors are permitted to deposit the published version in institutional and subject repositories, provided the original publication in this journal is acknowledged.
PIDCC charges no submission, processing or publication fees.
